Rare, Hard to Find, Sold Out, Discontinued, and Other Collectibles

Great prices on hallmark nativity! Shop our wide selection of hallmark nativity now!

Buy Hallmark Nativity

Looking for hallmark nativity? We feature a wide selection of hallmark nativity and related items. Shop now! Shop for Hallmark Nativity for sale at eBay.

Hallmark 2015 Limited Edition Peanuts Charlie Brown Nativity 10 Figurines New

​Hallmark 2015 - $299.95

Hallmark 2015 Limited Edition Peanuts Charlie Brown Nativity 10 Figurines New

Peanuts Snoopy Hallmark Christmas White Nativity Collection 10 Piece -le -new

​Peanuts Snoopy - $249.95

Peanuts Snoopy Hallmark Christmas White Nativity Collection 10 Piece -le -new

Retired New Hallmark Itty Bitty Nativity Complete Set 3 -pack 12 Pieces In All

​Retired New - $199.00

Retired New Hallmark Itty Bitty Nativity Complete Set 3 -pack 12 Pieces In All

Peanuts Snoopy Hallmark Christmas Nativity Collection 2 Parts -10 Pieces -new

​Peanuts Snoopy - $198.95

Peanuts Snoopy Hallmark Christmas Nativity Collection 2 Parts -10 Pieces -new

Hallmark 2005 Peanuts Christmas Pageant Nativity Club Exclusive Rare Ornament

​Hallmark 2005 - $150.00

Hallmark 2005 Peanuts Christmas Pageant Nativity Club Exclusive Rare Ornament

Rare Hallmark 1981 Ambassador Nativity Christmas Ornament By Holiday House Mint

​Rare Hallmark - $149.95

Rare Hallmark 1981 Ambassador Nativity Christmas Ornament By Holiday House Mint

Qx6523 Hallmark Keepsake, 'holy Family', Blessed Nativity Collection 1998-2000

​Qx6523 Hallmark - $149.00

Qx6523 Hallmark Keepsake, 'holy Family', Blessed Nativity Collection 1998-2000

Hallmark 10pc Porcelain Blessed Nativity Set Holy Family Kings Baby Jesus Manger

​Hallmark 10pc - $133.91

Hallmark 10pc Porcelain Blessed Nativity Set Holy Family Kings Baby Jesus Manger

Hallmark Itty Bittys Nativity Complete Collector Set Nib Plush Sheperd

​Hallmark Itty - $129.95

Hallmark Itty Bittys Nativity Complete Collector Set Nib Plush Sheperd

2005 Hallmark Nativity 10 Piece Collection Set 9” Rare-charity Sale

​2005 Hallmark - $99.99

2005 Hallmark Nativity 10 Piece Collection Set 9” Rare-charity Sale

Hallmark Mary Hamilton Nativity Set Figurines White Glazed 6 Little Gallery Pcs

​Hallmark Mary - $116.77

Hallmark Mary Hamilton Nativity Set Figurines White Glazed 6 Little Gallery Pcs

Hallmark Mary Hamilton Little Goose Girl 1988 Nativity Bisque Figurine

​Hallmark Mary - $112.49

Hallmark Mary Hamilton Little Goose Girl 1988 Nativity Bisque Figurine

Hallmark Mary Hamilton Starlight Angel 1986 Nativity Bisque Figurine

​Hallmark Mary - $112.49

Hallmark Mary Hamilton Starlight Angel 1986 Nativity Bisque Figurine

Hallmark Mary Hamilton Nativity Drummer Boy Figurine 1987 With Box

​Hallmark Mary - $112.45

Hallmark Mary Hamilton Nativity Drummer Boy Figurine 1987 With Box

Hallmark Peanuts Gallery Snoopy Christmas Nativity Figurine Set New

​Hallmark Peanuts - $99.90

Hallmark Peanuts Gallery Snoopy Christmas Nativity Figurine Set New

1979 Tiffany Classic Bethlehem Nativity Scene Acrylic Hallmark Ornament Mib

​1979 Tiffany - $99.98

1979 Tiffany Classic Bethlehem Nativity Scene Acrylic Hallmark Ornament Mib

1985 Nativity Scene Glass Hallmark Christmas Ornament Mib

​1985 Nativity - $99.98

1985 Nativity Scene Glass Hallmark Christmas Ornament Mib

Hallmark Exclusive 2012 Peanuts Gallery Nativity Figurines - Set Of 7 - Xkt103

​Hallmark Exclusive - $104.00

Hallmark Exclusive 2012 Peanuts Gallery Nativity Figurines - Set Of 7 - Xkt103

Hallmark 2009 Hall Family Story Of The Nativity Annual Christmas Ornament-vgc

​Hallmark 2009 - $103.45

Hallmark 2009 Hall Family Story Of The Nativity Annual Christmas Ornament-vgc

1983 Hallmark Qmb9049 Nativity Ornament

​1983 Hallmark - $99.99

1983 Hallmark Qmb9049 Nativity Ornament

Hallmark Peanuts Glad Tidings Nativity 7 Piece Set Charlie Brown Snoopy Gift S/o

​Hallmark Peanuts - $89.99

Hallmark Peanuts Glad Tidings Nativity 7 Piece Set Charlie Brown Snoopy Gift S/o

Hallmark Peanuts Gallery Nativity Ceramaic Shepard Holy Family Wise Christmas

​Hallmark Peanuts - $79.99

Hallmark Peanuts Gallery Nativity Ceramaic Shepard Holy Family Wise Christmas

Hallmark Keepsake Kids 7pc Wood Ornament Set Nativity Play Set In Its Own Stable

​Hallmark Keepsake - $79.99

Hallmark Keepsake Kids 7pc Wood Ornament Set Nativity Play Set In Its Own Stable

Hallmark 11pc Nativity Set Omura Collection Wood Manger Palm Tree Resin Figures

​Hallmark 11pc - $74.98

Hallmark 11pc Nativity Set Omura Collection Wood Manger Palm Tree Resin Figures

Peanuts Snoopy And Woodstock Hallmark Gallery Nativity Shepherd And Flock Ornament

​Peanuts Snoopy - $67.79

Peanuts Snoopy And Woodstock Hallmark Gallery Nativity Shepherd And Flock Ornament

Hallmark 2014-18 Peanuts Nativity Collection - 7 Figurines Xkt1037

​Hallmark 2014-18 - $69.99

Hallmark 2014-18 Peanuts Nativity Collection - 7 Figurines Xkt1037

Mint Hallmark Keepsake Set 8 Fine Porcelain Blessed Nativity Christmas Ornaments

​Mint Hallmark - $79.99

Mint Hallmark Keepsake Set 8 Fine Porcelain Blessed Nativity Christmas Ornaments

Hallmark 2012 The Nativity Collection Set Of 6 Porcelain Signed By Mary Hamilton

​Hallmark 2012 - $69.95

Hallmark 2012 The Nativity Collection Set Of 6 Porcelain Signed By Mary Hamilton

Hallmark Ceramic Nativity Set 8 Figurines

​Hallmark Ceramic - $77.00

Hallmark Ceramic Nativity Set 8 Figurines

2000 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament The Shepherds Blessed Nativity Collection

​2000 Hallmark - $74.95

2000 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament The Shepherds Blessed Nativity Collection

Hallmark 2014 Glad Tidings Nativity Peanuts Gallery Figurines - Set Of 7 -

​Hallmark 2014 - $73.65

Hallmark 2014 Glad Tidings Nativity Peanuts Gallery Figurines - Set Of 7 -

 3 1984 Hallmark Nativity Star Over Bethlehem Christmas Ornaments Bible

​ 3 - $73.47

3 1984 Hallmark Nativity Star Over Bethlehem Christmas Ornaments Bible

2015 Hallmark Peanuts Nativity Accessories New In Box 4 Piece Figurines Set

​2015 Hallmark - $72.99

2015 Hallmark Peanuts Nativity Accessories New In Box 4 Piece Figurines Set

8586 Nrfb Hallmark Collector's Club 2001 Nesting Nativity Ornament

​8586 Nrfb - $71.99

8586 Nrfb Hallmark Collector's Club 2001 Nesting Nativity Ornament

Hallmark Itty Bittys Complete Nativity Set Jesus Mary Joseph Wise Men Sheep Nib

​Hallmark Itty - $64.99

Hallmark Itty Bittys Complete Nativity Set Jesus Mary Joseph Wise Men Sheep Nib

Rare Hallmark Eight Piece Holy Nativity Set Christmas Ornaments Or Display 1998

​Rare Hallmark - $32.95

Rare Hallmark Eight Piece Holy Nativity Set Christmas Ornaments Or Display 1998

1987 9 Pcs Precious Moments Nativity Figurine Come Let Us Adore Him Hallmark Mib

​1987 9 - $70.95

1987 9 Pcs Precious Moments Nativity Figurine Come Let Us Adore Him Hallmark Mib

Hallmark- Glad Tidings Peanut Nativity 7pc Set Limited Edition Nib

​Hallmark- Glad - $70.00

Hallmark- Glad Tidings Peanut Nativity 7pc Set Limited Edition Nib

Vintage 6 Piece Nativity Set By Kelli Bread Dough Style In Hallmark Box

​Vintage 6 - $69.00

Vintage 6 Piece Nativity Set By Kelli Bread Dough Style In Hallmark Box

Hallmark 2006 Nativity Set 5 Piece Light Of The World

​Hallmark 2006 - $50.00

Hallmark 2006 Nativity Set 5 Piece Light Of The World

Hallmark Itty Bittys Nativity Set + Wise Men W/sheep Collector Sets Nib

​Hallmark Itty - $55.00

Hallmark Itty Bittys Nativity Set + Wise Men W/sheep Collector Sets Nib

Hallmark Peanuts Noel Nativity Water Globe Nwt

​Hallmark Peanuts - $58.99

Hallmark Peanuts Noel Nativity Water Globe Nwt

The Shepherds Ornaments Set 2000 The Blessed Nativity Collection Hallmark Nmib

​The Shepherds - $51.51

The Shepherds Ornaments Set 2000 The Blessed Nativity Collection Hallmark Nmib

Hallmark 2012 Peanuts Gallery Nativity Collection 7 Figures Complete Set

​Hallmark 2012 - $65.99

Hallmark 2012 Peanuts Gallery Nativity Collection 7 Figures Complete Set

Hallmark Itty Bittys Nativity And Wise Men Collector Sets New

​Hallmark Itty - $65.00

Hallmark Itty Bittys Nativity And Wise Men Collector Sets New

Hallmark Keepsake Holy Family Nativity Figurines

​Hallmark Keepsake - $65.00

Hallmark Keepsake Holy Family Nativity Figurines

Hallmark Christmas Itty Bitty Nativity And Wise Men Collector Sets

​Hallmark Christmas - $64.88

Hallmark Christmas Itty Bitty Nativity And Wise Men Collector Sets

Hallmark Itty Bittys Complete Nativity Set Mary, Joseph Jesus, Wise Men Nib

​Hallmark Itty - $64.50

Hallmark Itty Bittys Complete Nativity Set Mary, Joseph Jesus, Wise Men Nib

Hallmark Keepsake First Christmas 25 Day Countdown To Christmas Nativity 2005

​Hallmark Keepsake - $49.00

Hallmark Keepsake First Christmas 25 Day Countdown To Christmas Nativity 2005

Hallmark Vintage Merry Miniature Nativity Complete Set 1988/1989

​Hallmark Vintage - $61.99

Hallmark Vintage Merry Miniature Nativity Complete Set 1988/1989

Lot Of Hallmark Ornaments Blessed Nativity Collection Complete Set W/ Angel

​Lot Of - $49.99

Lot Of Hallmark Ornaments Blessed Nativity Collection Complete Set W/ Angel

Hallmark Ornament 2012 Nativity Story Magic Light And Sound

​Hallmark Ornament - $60.00

Hallmark Ornament 2012 Nativity Story Magic Light And Sound

Hallmark Peanuts Snoopy + Nativity Lot Of Christmas Cards 4 Boxes 96 Cards

​Hallmark Peanuts - $49.99

Hallmark Peanuts Snoopy + Nativity Lot Of Christmas Cards 4 Boxes 96 Cards

Hallmark Blessed Nativity-complete Collection

​Hallmark Blessed - $59.99

Hallmark Blessed Nativity-complete Collection

Hallmark Keepsake Christmas Ornament Lot Religious Nativity Angel Madonna

​Hallmark Keepsake - $59.99

Hallmark Keepsake Christmas Ornament Lot Religious Nativity Angel Madonna

Hallmark Itty Bittys Nativity Collector Sets Exclusive 8 Pieces - Nib

​Hallmark Itty - $49.99

Hallmark Itty Bittys Nativity Collector Sets Exclusive 8 Pieces - Nib

Vintage Hallmark Porcelain Nativity Scene W/ Votive Candle

​Vintage Hallmark - $49.98

Vintage Hallmark Porcelain Nativity Scene W/ Votive Candle

Hallmark Blessed Nativity Collection

​Hallmark Blessed - $59.02

Hallmark Blessed Nativity Collection

Dayspring Hallmark Christmas Advent Nativity Calendar, 8 Pieces 25-day Countdown

​Dayspring Hallmark - $39.99

Dayspring Hallmark Christmas Advent Nativity Calendar, 8 Pieces 25-day Countdown

1993 He Is Born Nativity Hallmark Christmas Ornament Mib

​1993 He - $49.98

1993 He Is Born Nativity Hallmark Christmas Ornament Mib

Hallmark Keepsake 2000 The Shepherds Blessed Nativity Collection Porcelain

​Hallmark Keepsake - $54.99

Hallmark Keepsake 2000 The Shepherds Blessed Nativity Collection Porcelain

2001 Hallmark Ornament Nesting Nativity Set Of Five - Pressed Tin

​2001 Hallmark - $54.99

2001 Hallmark Ornament Nesting Nativity Set Of Five - Pressed Tin

Hallmark 2006 Light Of The World Table Decoration 5 Piece Nativity Set New

​Hallmark 2006 - $54.95

Hallmark 2006 Light Of The World Table Decoration 5 Piece Nativity Set New

1983 Hallmark Christmas Musical Ornament Nativity Silent Night Holiday Qmb904-9

​1983 Hallmark - $49.99

1983 Hallmark Christmas Musical Ornament Nativity Silent Night Holiday Qmb904-9

 Hallmark Keepsake 3-piece Three Wise Men Large Nativity Collection Bnib

​ Hallmark - $37.99

Hallmark Keepsake 3-piece Three Wise Men Large Nativity Collection Bnib

Hallmark Mary Hamilton Heavenly Angel 1985 Nativity Bisque Figurine

​Hallmark Mary - $50.99

Hallmark Mary Hamilton Heavenly Angel 1985 Nativity Bisque Figurine

2017 Hallmark Nativity Set Of 3 Pieces New In Box

​2017 Hallmark - $45.00

2017 Hallmark Nativity Set Of 3 Pieces New In Box

Hallmark 2005 Nativity Play Set

​Hallmark 2005 - $50.09

Hallmark 2005 Nativity Play Set

1989 Hallmark The First Noel Fine Porcelain Creche Christmas Nativity

​1989 Hallmark - $35.00

1989 Hallmark The First Noel Fine Porcelain Creche Christmas Nativity

Hallmark Charlie Brown Christmas Nativity Collection - 7 Figurines - Nib

​Hallmark Charlie - $50.00

Hallmark Charlie Brown Christmas Nativity Collection - 7 Figurines - Nib

Hallmark 1998 - 1999 Blessed Nativity Collection 4-box Set, Mib Nib

​Hallmark 1998 - $50.00

Hallmark 1998 - 1999 Blessed Nativity Collection 4-box Set, Mib Nib

2006 Hallmark Light Of The World 5-pc Nativity Set With Angel And Baby Jesus Mib

​2006 Hallmark - $49.99

2006 Hallmark Light Of The World 5-pc Nativity Set With Angel And Baby Jesus Mib

New Hallmark 3 Wise Men Itty Bitty Plush Doll Bittys 5 Christmas Nativity Set

​New Hallmark - $49.99

New Hallmark 3 Wise Men Itty Bitty Plush Doll Bittys 5 Christmas Nativity Set

Hallmark Nativity Stable Nine Figures Merry Miniatures 1988 Collection 3 Extras

​Hallmark Nativity - $49.99

Hallmark Nativity Stable Nine Figures Merry Miniatures 1988 Collection 3 Extras

1978 Holiday Highlights Nativity Hallmark Keepsake Acrylic Ornament Christmas

​1978 Holiday - $49.99

1978 Holiday Highlights Nativity Hallmark Keepsake Acrylic Ornament Christmas

1978 Holiday Highlights Nativity Hallmark Keepsake Acrylic Ornament

​1978 Holiday - $49.99

1978 Holiday Highlights Nativity Hallmark Keepsake Acrylic Ornament

2014 Hallmark The Nativity Collection Mary Hamilton Set Of 6 Loc B48

​2014 Hallmark - $49.95

2014 Hallmark The Nativity Collection Mary Hamilton Set Of 6 Loc B48

Wise Men Nativity Set Joanne Eschrich Collection - Hallmark Tabletop Display

​Wise Men - $39.95

Wise Men Nativity Set Joanne Eschrich Collection - Hallmark Tabletop Display

Manger Nativity Set Joanne Eschrich Collection - Hallmark Tabletop Display

​Manger Nativity - $39.95

Manger Nativity Set Joanne Eschrich Collection - Hallmark Tabletop Display