Rare, Hard to Find, Sold Out, Discontinued, and Other Collectibles

Great prices on painted ponies! Shop our wide selection of painted ponies now!

Buy Painted Ponies

Looking for painted ponies? We feature a wide selection of painted ponies and related items. Shop now! Shop for Painted Ponies for sale at eBay.

Peacemaker Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Horse Topp Honorable Mention Winner

​Peacemaker Trail - $645.00

Peacemaker Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Horse Topp Honorable Mention Winner

Trail Of Painted Ponies War Pony Figurine Pre-e 0178 - Very Rare - Free Shipping

​Trail Of - $599.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies War Pony Figurine Pre-e 0178 - Very Rare - Free Shipping

Trail Of Painted Ponies Fireman Pony Figurine Pre-e 0017 - Rare - Free Shipping

​Trail Of - $599.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Fireman Pony Figurine Pre-e 0017 - Rare - Free Shipping

Trail Of Painted Ponies Fireman Pony Figurine Pre-e 0022 - Rare - Free Shipping

​Trail Of - $599.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Fireman Pony Figurine Pre-e 0022 - Rare - Free Shipping

Trail Of Painted Ponies Motorcycle Mustang Figurine Pre-e 0221 - Free Shipping

​Trail Of - $599.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Motorcycle Mustang Figurine Pre-e 0221 - Free Shipping

Trail Of Painted Ponies Karuna Figurine Pre-e 0075 - Very Rare - Free Shipping

​Trail Of - $599.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Karuna Figurine Pre-e 0075 - Very Rare - Free Shipping

Westland Trail Of The Painted Ponies War Horse 1477 First Edition In Black Box

​Westland Trail - $500.00

Westland Trail Of The Painted Ponies War Horse 1477 First Edition In Black Box

Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Horse Jumping For Joy Abstract Art J. Leigh

​Trail Of - $499.95

Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Horse Jumping For Joy Abstract Art J. Leigh

Phoenix Pony Trail Of Painted Ponies Limited First Edition Signed Sculpture Df

​Phoenix Pony - $499.99

Phoenix Pony Trail Of Painted Ponies Limited First Edition Signed Sculpture Df

Trail Of Painted Ponies War Pony Figurine Pre-e 2832 - Very Rare - Free Shipping

​Trail Of - $499.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies War Pony Figurine Pre-e 2832 - Very Rare - Free Shipping

Trail Of Painted Ponies Caballo Brilliante Figurine Pre-e 3442 - Free Shipping

​Trail Of - $499.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Caballo Brilliante Figurine Pre-e 3442 - Free Shipping

Trail Of Painted Ponies Caballo Brilliante Figurine Pre-e 3449 - Free Shipping

​Trail Of - $499.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Caballo Brilliante Figurine Pre-e 3449 - Free Shipping

Trail Of Painted Ponies Caballo Brilliante Figurine Pre-e 3410 - Free Shipping

​Trail Of - $499.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Caballo Brilliante Figurine Pre-e 3410 - Free Shipping

Rogue Stallion Painted Ponies Custom Horse Canvas Art

​Rogue Stallion - $495.00

Rogue Stallion Painted Ponies Custom Horse Canvas Art

Mosaic Appaloosa Artist Signed 1e/3,396 Painted Ponies By Westland, 1466

​Mosaic Appaloosa - $489.50

Mosaic Appaloosa Artist Signed 1e/3,396 Painted Ponies By Westland, 1466

Trail Of The Painted Ponies - Reflections Of Australia Was An Exclusive Release

​Trail Of - $400.20

Trail Of The Painted Ponies - Reflections Of Australia Was An Exclusive Release

Custom Trail Of Painted Ponies Dragon Heart Chinese Art Horse By J. Leigh

​Custom Trail - $459.95

Custom Trail Of Painted Ponies Dragon Heart Chinese Art Horse By J. Leigh

Trail Of Painted Ponies Wildfire, 1e, Black Box,very Rare, Fire Horse

​Trail Of - $449.99

Trail Of Painted Ponies Wildfire, 1e, Black Box,very Rare, Fire Horse

Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Horse Autumn Fall Pony Foliage Filly J. Leigh

​Trail Of - $399.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Horse Autumn Fall Pony Foliage Filly J. Leigh

Custom Trail Of Painted Ponies Star Catcher Abstract Horse By J. Leigh

​Custom Trail - $395.00

Custom Trail Of Painted Ponies Star Catcher Abstract Horse By J. Leigh

Trail Of Painted Ponies Motorcycle Mustang Figurine Pre-e 3,355 Rare Find

​Trail Of - $400.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Motorcycle Mustang Figurine Pre-e 3,355 Rare Find

Complete Set Of 12 Celebrations Minis Retired Trail Of Painted Ponies Nib 2011

​Complete Set - $400.00

Complete Set Of 12 Celebrations Minis Retired Trail Of Painted Ponies Nib 2011

Trail Of Painted Ponies Unity Rare/retired 1e0509

​Trail Of - $399.99

Trail Of Painted Ponies Unity Rare/retired 1e0509

Trail Of The Painted Ponies Boot Scootin Horsey Pre E 0416

​Trail Of - $399.99

Trail Of The Painted Ponies Boot Scootin Horsey Pre E 0416

Painted Ponies Shatka Bear-step Hard Cover Book 1st Edition With Additions

​Painted Ponies - $395.00

Painted Ponies Shatka Bear-step Hard Cover Book 1st Edition With Additions

Wildfire Trail Of Painted Ponies By Westland, 1458 1e / 1,140 Black Box

​Wildfire Trail - $389.50

Wildfire Trail Of Painted Ponies By Westland, 1458 1e / 1,140 Black Box

High Desert Horse Feather Trail Of Painted Ponies By Weatland, 11254 1e/0531

​High Desert - $389.50

High Desert Horse Feather Trail Of Painted Ponies By Weatland, 11254 1e/0531

Trail Of Painted Ponies Unity Rare/retired 1e/2727

​Trail Of - $379.99

Trail Of Painted Ponies Unity Rare/retired 1e/2727

The Trail Of Painted Ponies 1e/3933 Mosaic Appaloosa 1466 Beautiful Rare

​The Trail - $374.99

The Trail Of Painted Ponies 1e/3933 Mosaic Appaloosa 1466 Beautiful Rare

Eagle Feather Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Horse Native American J. Leigh

​Eagle Feather - $349.95

Eagle Feather Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Horse Native American J. Leigh

Trail Of Painted Ponies Butterflies Run Free Figurine 6.25 In

​Trail Of - $343.65

Trail Of Painted Ponies Butterflies Run Free Figurine 6.25 In

Bengali Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Tiger Horse Hand Painted Pony J.leigh

​Bengali Trail - $329.95

Bengali Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Tiger Horse Hand Painted Pony J.leigh

Retired And Rare - Appaloosa Peacock - Trail Of Painted Ponies - 1e/ 3163

​Retired And - $340.00

Retired And Rare - Appaloosa Peacock - Trail Of Painted Ponies - 1e/ 3163

 Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Holiday On Ice Aaopp Artist Painted

​ Trail - $333.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Holiday On Ice Aaopp Artist Painted

Trail Of The Painted Ponies Go Van Gogh 1e / 6701 Autographed - Never Displayed

​Trail Of - $300.00

Trail Of The Painted Ponies Go Van Gogh 1e / 6701 Autographed - Never Displayed

 Trail Of Painted Ponies War Pony  1452 1e / 6487 Bnib Mib Rare

​ Trail - $299.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies War Pony 1452 1e / 6487 Bnib Mib Rare

Snow Bound Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Horse Pony J. Leigh

​Snow Bound - $295.00

Snow Bound Trail Of Painted Ponies Custom Horse Pony J. Leigh

 Trail Of Painted Ponies Five Card Stud 1459 1e / 1802 Bnib Mib Rare

​ Trail - $289.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Five Card Stud 1459 1e / 1802 Bnib Mib Rare

Painted Ponies Fetish Pony 9and 6

​Painted Ponies - $275.00

Painted Ponies Fetish Pony 9and 6

Trail Of Painted Ponies Angels On High Hanging Ornament

​Trail Of - $300.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Angels On High Hanging Ornament

Trail Of Painted Ponies Year Of The Horse 12390 Artist Lori Musil 2007

​Trail Of - $275.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Year Of The Horse 12390 Artist Lori Musil 2007

The Trail Of Painted Ponies Wound Up Time On The Range First Edition 1e / 8434

​The Trail - $275.00

The Trail Of Painted Ponies Wound Up Time On The Range First Edition 1e / 8434

Ceremonial Pony Trail Of Painted Ponies By Westland, 12255 Le Signed, 1e/0538

​Ceremonial Pony - $289.50

Ceremonial Pony Trail Of Painted Ponies By Westland, 12255 Le Signed, 1e/0538

Anasazi Spirit Horse Trail Of Painted Ponies By Westland, 1583 1e/8,147 Signed

​Anasazi Spirit - $289.50

Anasazi Spirit Horse Trail Of Painted Ponies By Westland, 1583 1e/8,147 Signed

Happy Trails, Palomino Trail Of Painted Ponies By Westland, 1473 1e / 6,993

​Happy Trails, - $289.50

Happy Trails, Palomino Trail Of Painted Ponies By Westland, 1473 1e / 6,993

Trail Of The Painted Ponies Lamp - 9 Tall Copper Enchantment Table Lamp New

​Trail Of - $250.00

Trail Of The Painted Ponies Lamp - 9 Tall Copper Enchantment Table Lamp New

Retired/very Rare - Reflections Of Australia - Trail Of Painted Ponies - 1e/1993

​Retired/very Rare - $270.00

Retired/very Rare - Reflections Of Australia - Trail Of Painted Ponies - 1e/1993

Trail Of The Painted Ponies 8 War Pony 1452 Westland 2003 Horse Mint In Blk Box

​Trail Of - $249.00

Trail Of The Painted Ponies 8 War Pony 1452 Westland 2003 Horse Mint In Blk Box

New In Box Trail Of The Painted Ponies 4030258 El Dorado Horse Figurine

​New In - $160.36

New In Box Trail Of The Painted Ponies 4030258 El Dorado Horse Figurine

Retired 1e Painted Ponies 12305 Native Essence 0066 Resin Horse Figurine Bnib

​Retired 1e - $250.00

Retired 1e Painted Ponies 12305 Native Essence 0066 Resin Horse Figurine Bnib

Trail Of Painted Ponies Willing Rare/retired 1e0579

​Trail Of - $250.00

Trail Of Painted Ponies Willing Rare/retired 1e0579

 Trail Of Painted Ponies Quarter Horse Signed No Box Or Tag Free Insured Ship

​ Trail - $249.99

Trail Of Painted Ponies Quarter Horse Signed No Box Or Tag Free Insured Ship

Phoenix Pony Trail Of Painted Ponies Limited First Edition Signed Sculpture

​Phoenix Pony - $249.99

Phoenix Pony Trail Of Painted Ponies Limited First Edition Signed Sculpture

 Painted Ponies Fetish Large Signed X 3 Retired Limited Edition 120/5,000

​ Painted - $249.99

Painted Ponies Fetish Large Signed X 3 Retired Limited Edition 120/5,000

Unity Trail Of Painted Ponies By Westland, 1468 1e/1,401 2004 Black Box, Tag

​Unity Trail - $248.50

Unity Trail Of Painted Ponies By Westland, 1468 1e/1,401 2004 Black Box, Tag